Skip to Content Skip to Footer
Make Them Type the Promo Code: Why a Little Effort Beats an Automatic Discount in Digital Shopping

Make Them Type the Promo Code: Why a Little Effort Beats an Automatic Discount in Digital Shopping

Wenkai Song and Joycee Wilson Pol

Journal of Marketing Research Scholarly Insights are produced in partnership with the AMA Doctoral Students SIG – a shared interest network for Marketing PhD students across the world.

Think about the last time you checked out online. Somewhere near the total, there was probably a small box asking for a promo code. Typing one takes mere seconds, yet it represents the kind of friction most marketers try to design away. Why make customers do something so trivial when you could simply give them 15% off?

In a recent Journal of Marketing Research study, researchers found that this small box does more work than it might seem. Asking shoppers to enter a code or click through a single CAPTCHA produces higher redemption rates than automatically applying an identical discount. They call this the token-effort effect, and it runs directly against conventional wisdom: When the authors asked participants to imagine themselves as the seller, 79% predicted that the automatic discount would sell better.

What Happened When Customers Had to Type the Code

The clearest test came from a real campaign. Working with Zoka Coffee, a U.S. roastery and coffeehouse chain, the authors ran an A/B test on an email promoting a new Spring Blend to 6,623 customers. Half were told to enter the code SB15OFF to unlock 15% off. The other half were simply told that they were getting 15% off. Customers in both cases could click the “Order Now” button in the email to get directed to the product landing page on the company’s official website. The code version converted at 1.45% compared with 0.91% for the automatic discount—roughly a 60% lift from the same offer at the same margin.

A follow-up campaign on Facebook and Instagram that reached nearly 93,000 people showed a similar pattern in click-through rates, and other controlled studies with real stakes supported these findings as well.

Why a Trivial Task Adds Value

The mechanism is not that people think the discount is bigger. When the researchers measured how much value shoppers felt they received from the final price, they found no difference between the two conditions. What changes is who gets credit for the discount. Entering a code makes it feel earned, and that sense of responsibility leads to a quick judgment: A few keystrokes bought me 20% off, which is an excellent return on my effort. This judgment increases redemption both directly and through the satisfying feeling of having pulled off a small win.

Entering the code makes it feel earned, and that sense of responsibility leads to a quick judgment: A few keystrokes bought me 20% off, which is an excellent return on my effort.

Where It Stops Working

The effort has to stay genuinely trivial. When participants had to solve 20 CAPTCHAs for the same 40% discount, redemption fell to 53%—no better than the automatic discount, and well below the single-CAPTCHA condition at 74%. The effort must be small enough to feel rewarding. Twenty CAPTCHAs for the same discount performed no better than handing it over for free.

Attention matters too. When participants were asked to reflect on the money they were about to spend before making their purchase decision, the effect disappeared. This prompted them to focus on the price and disrupted their assessment of whether the reward was worth the effort..

Key Takeaways for Marketers

A promo code is not a barrier to sales. Rather, it is part of the offer, and marketers who default to automatic discounts are giving away the same margin for less in return. The requirement must stay small enough that customers never weigh it as a burden, thus ruling out more demanding actions such as completing surveys or sharing content in social media groups. The tactic also depends on customers noticing this exchange of value, so promotions built around a headline price will suppress its effects.

We spoke with the authors about what led them to consider that friction might help, why the tactic matters most for the modest discounts, and whether it survives auto-apply coupon extensions and AI shopping agents.

Q: This research shows that a token redemption effort, like entering a promo code, increased redemption rates over an equivalent straight discount. What led you to consider that adding friction to the redemption process could actually help rather than hurt sales?

A: As consumer researchers ourselves, we began with multiple observations in the marketplace. We sensed that when consumers exert little effort to get something, they are more likely to claim the discount. Unlike traditional coupons, which operate around redemption friction, digital coupons can be delivered almost entirely frictionlessly. This led us to ask: If digital shopping can be frictionless, why do firms still use mechanisms like promo codes or click-to-claim offers? Our findings suggest that these small, token efforts do more than create an irritating obstacle; they can create a sense of responsibility for the discount and positive utility for consumers.

Q: Many retailers already use other effort-based mechanics, such as loyalty points or program tiers. How does the token-effort effect interact with these mechanisms, and whether layering multiple “effort” touchpoints might backfire?

A: Our paper focuses on situations involving a trivial amount of effort compared with no effort; it does not examine systems that impose multiple, repeated hurdles. We would expect a tipping point at which the accumulation of small efforts begins to feel irritating or aversive, causing the positive effect to weaken or disappear. The key factor is that the effort must remain sufficiently trivial to avoid triggering annoyance. The effect emerges when consumers think, in essence, “I only need to do something very small, yet I receive a meaningful reward in return.” Once the effort no longer feels trivial, this positive return-on-effort thinking breaks down.

Q: Does habituation (if consumers do this repeatedly) wear out this effect?

A: This is an empirical question. Over time, if consumers become completely used to these promotions or recognize them as a company-added friction tactic, the effect could weaken. However, based on my personal experience, the effect still seems to operate even when one knows the mechanism. For example, I regularly buy coffee at my school coffee shop, which asks customers to enter a promo code for 10% off rather than simply applying the discount automatically. Despite the familiarity of this practice, entering the code can still make the discount feel earned and enhance consumers’ perception that they are receiving a good deal. Promotional codes have existed for decades, yet they remain widely used. Our research suggests that the trivial effort required to redeem them creates a favorable sense of return on effort and thereby increases consumers’ likelihood to claim the promotion.

Q: The effect showed up across discount depths from 10% to 40% off but weakened at very high discounts like 70% off. What should a manager selling a big-ticket item or running a steep clearance sale take from that?

A: One of the most interesting findings from this research is that the token effort is particularly useful for boosting the effectiveness of small to moderate discounts, especially those in the 10%–15% range, which prior work suggests are not particularly effective. Our research shows that requiring a trivial redemption effort can make these discounts substantially more effective than applying them automatically. In situations where firms cannot afford steep discounts, this friction of entering a promo code during checkout is especially useful. Instead of increasing the size of the discount, managers may be able to increase effectiveness by adding a small redemption action. For clearance sales or very high discounts, the difference matters less, because when the discount is already very large, consumers naturally have a high willingness to avail it, leaving relatively little room for token effort to generate an additional effect.

Q: Your findings show that consumers need to feel personally responsible for redeeming a discount for the token-effort effect to work. But today, auto-apply coupon extensions and AI shopping agents are doing the code-entering for consumers, and promo codes are becoming so common that entering one may start to feel like routine checkout rather than a meaningful action. Do you think the effect holds up against these?

A: The key issue is whether consumers feel personally responsible for obtaining the discount. When AI or automation makes the process feel fully automatic, the sense of responsibility and ownership over the discount may weaken, reducing the effectiveness of token effort. At the same time, an important question is: To what extent do customers attribute the process to the AI shopping agent or to themselves? If consumers feel that using AI effectively to use the promo codes themselves is a kind of skillful action, they may still experience a sense of responsibility, almost a new form of return on effort, where the effort is in learning or deploying the tool well. In that case, the effect could persist as customers may feel like smart shoppers when the AI agent secures the promotion on their behalf, provided that the outcome does not feel completely detached from their own actions.

Q: In the paper, you suggest token effort could be used beyond price promotions, such as encouraging people to join exercise programs. At the same time, firms can use it as a costless way to boost sales by adding friction. How do you draw the line between a helpful nudge and a manipulative tactic, and what should guide its use for consumer welfare?

A: We do not view this as manipulative in the context we study because consumers have agency over their decision and receive a genuine discount; they are simply asked to complete a trivial task to obtain it. In our view, manipulation would mean steering consumers toward actions that are against their interests, that they do not fully understand, or that exploit their vulnerability during the purchase process. Token effort does not operate in this way. Rather than deceiving consumers into purchasing something they do not want, it can increase their appreciation of the discount and strengthen their sense of responsibility for obtaining it. Within the conditions examined in our research, token effort therefore does not appear to diminish consumer welfare; instead, it may enhance consumers’ perceived utility from the promotion.

Q: Does product type matter for this effect, like hedonic versus utilitarian?

A: In an initial study, we examined whether the effect differed between hedonic products and utilitarian products. The effect emerged for both product types, including hedonic products such as chocolate and utilitarian products such as a USB cable.

Q: Can this apply beyond discounts, such as exercise programs or vaccinations? Since exercise itself already feels effortful, how would this work there?

A: We think so and seek to extend our findings to other contexts. The key is not to add substantial effort to the target behavior itself but to introduce a small action to unlock participation. For example, one version of an exercise program might enroll people automatically, while another might require a token effort or step to sign up. The version requiring a token effort could increase the likelihood of sign-up because the small effort creates a positive perception of return on effort. This does not imply imposing additional burdens on behaviors that are already demanding. Rather, the logic applies only when the incremental action remains small and manageable.

Q: How would you convince a manager who is thinking of removing all frictions with your research?

A: It is important to make consumers more aware and appreciative of the benefits they receive. A small amount of friction is not necessarily detrimental. When discounts are applied entirely automatically, consumers may feel less personally responsible for obtaining them, weakening their sense of ownership over the deal. In contrast, a trivial redemption effort can make consumers feel like smart shoppers who have successfully secured a good deal. Thus, removing all friction may not always be the most effective approach; in some cases, preserving a small, manageable action can make a promotion more effective.

Read the Full Study for Complete Details

Source: Kuangjie Zhang, Thomas Allard, Nidhi Agrawal, and Rajesh Bagchi (2025), “The Token-Effort Effect: Trivial Redemption Effort Increases Price Promotion Effectiveness,” Journal of Marketing Research, 62 (6), 1125–41. doi:10.1177/00222437251338050.

Go to the Journal of Marketing Research

Related Articles

Wenkai Song is a doctoral student in marketing, University of Utah, USA.

Joycee Wilson Pol is a doctoral student in marketing, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee, India.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.