Contrary to the intuition that salespeople gravitate toward big-whale sales opportunities, in reality they often avoid them. A new Journal of Marketing study integrates contingent decision-making and conservation-of-resources theories to develop and test a framework of salespeople’s decision making while prospecting. Findings from three multimethod studies enrich current understanding of this important salesperson behavior.
Our research team makes three contributions to marketing literature. First, by showing that salespeople conduct rational benefit–cost analyses to decide what opportunity to pursue, we shed light on the tension underlying such decisions and challenge the intuition that salespeople gravitate toward large opportunities (i.e., big whales). The benefits can be intrinsic and extrinsic, while the costs can be explicit (e.g., resources such as time and effort) or implicit (i.e., opportunity costs). Second, our study demonstrates that salespeople use a calibration decision-making strategy (i.e., calculating expected benefits by accounting for conversion uncertainty) for solution selling at the portfolio level. Counterfactual analyses show that in solution selling, ignoring the calibration effect leads to serious under- or overestimation of conversion rates, sometimes up to 100%.
Third, our findings about the contingencies of the calibration effect pinpoint important biases in salesperson decision-making. Specifically, when faced with high levels of conversion uncertainty, high performers and inexperienced salespeople perform much worse because their resource-conserving tendency makes them more sensitive to the costs associated with uncertainty. Simulations reveal that when high performers or inexperienced salespeople believe their portfolio magnitude is large and conversion uncertainty is low, their quota attainment can improve by as much as 50%. These results call for further research to apply decision-making theories to personal selling when efforts are costly and resources limited.
For practitioners, our study reveals actionable ways for managers to: (1) successfully manage salespeople’s avoidance of relatively large opportunities; (2) better understand the role of conversion uncertainty in salesperson decision making while prospecting; and (3) effectively manage salespeople’s decision-making when prospecting by altering their benefit–cost calculus and uncertainty calibration and paying attention to salespeople’s portfolio characteristics.
Read the authors’ slides for sharing this material in your classroom.
From: Juan Xu, Michel Van der Borgh, Edwin J. Nijssen, and Son K. Lam, “Why Salespeople Avoid Big-Whale Sales Opportunities,” Journal of Marketing.
Go to the Journal of Marketing
Juan Xu is Assistant Professor of Marketing, NEOMA Business School, France.
Michel van der Borgh is Associate Professor of Marketing, Copenhagen Business School, Denmark.
Edwin J. Nijssen is Professor of Technology Marketing, Eindhoven University of Technology, Netherlands.
Son K. Lam is Professor of Marketing, University of Georgia, USA.