Content marketing generates plenty of data—but data alone doesn’t tell you what’s working, what’s not, or what to do next.
The Content Marketing Scorecard is a practical, spreadsheet-based framework designed to help marketers evaluate and track the effectiveness of their content marketing efforts across key performance areas. Instead of overwhelming dashboards or rigid vendor tools, this scorecard helps teams step back, assess performance honestly, and focus on the actions that matter most.
It’s simple by design—so it actually gets used.
Get Full Access to This Resource With AMA Membership
Why Use the Content Marketing Scorecard
Most content teams don’t struggle with measurement. They struggle with prioritization.
The Content Marketing Scorecard helps you:
- Move beyond activity metrics to meaningful evaluation
- Identify what’s truly driving results—and what isn’t
- Create alignment across teams and stakeholders
- Turn performance insights into clear next steps
By scoring performance consistently over time, teams can spot trends, focus resources, and improve outcomes—without adding complexity to their workflow.
What You’ll Get
When you download the Content Marketing Scorecard, you’ll receive:
- A spreadsheet-based scorecard template (Google Sheets or Excel)
- Pre-filled examples showing realistic performance and scoring
- Built-in status indicators to highlight what’s on track and what needs attention
- A simple action tracker to turn insights into next steps
- Clear guidance on how to score honestly and consistently
Everything is designed to be usable immediately—no setup, no integrations, no software required.
Key Benefits
Using the Content Marketing Scorecard helps teams:
- Gain a clear, high-level view of content marketing performance
- Focus on improvement areas instead of vanity metrics
- Create consistency in how performance is evaluated over time
- Align teams and stakeholders around shared priorities
- Turn reporting into action—not just documentation
The result is better decision-making, not more data.
How To Use This Template
Most teams follow this simple monthly workflow:
- Update performance data
Enter the most recent results for each KPI using your existing analytics tools. - Score performance honestly
Assign a score from 1–5 based on how results compare to targets. - Review overall performance
Use the roll-up summary to understand what’s working and where attention is needed. - Identify priority areas
Focus on KPIs marked At Risk or Off Track. - Assign actions
Document specific next steps, owners, and timelines in the Action Tracker. - Revisit next month
Track progress, adjust scores, and refine actions over time.
The process typically takes 30–45 minutes per month.
Content Marketing Scorecard Features and Capabilities
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Scorecard Overview | Evaluate content performance across core strategic areas using simple, consistent scoring |
| KPI Definitions | Standardize how metrics are measured to ensure clarity and alignment |
| Auto Status Indicators | Automatically flag KPIs as On Track, At Risk, or Off Track based on scores |
| Optional Weighting | Apply weights to KPIs when certain areas matter more than others |
| Roll-Up Summary | View overall performance trends and health at a glance |
| Action Tracker | Translate low scores into specific, accountable next steps |
| Pre-Filled Example | See a realistic, completed scorecard to guide first-time use |
| Spreadsheet-Based Format | Works in Google Sheets or Excel—no software required |
Solving Common Problems with This Template
| Challenge | Toolkit Solution |
|---|---|
| Too many metrics and no clarity | Focuses on a small set of meaningful performance areas |
| Dashboards that don’t drive action | Built-in action tracking tied directly to scores |
| Inconsistent or subjective reporting | Clear scoring guidance and standardized KPIs |
| Overly complex tools that go unused | Simple spreadsheet format that fits existing workflows |
| Difficulty explaining performance to stakeholders | Roll-up summary that shows overall health at a glance |
Tips for Getting the Most Value
- Be consistent. Use the same KPIs and targets for at least a quarter before making changes.
- Normalize “At Risk.” A score of 3 is common and useful—it highlights where to focus next.
- Keep actions specific. If an action feels vague, it won’t drive improvement.
Look for trends, not perfection. Progress over time matters more than any single score. - Use it in conversations. The scorecard is most powerful when reviewed with your team or stakeholders.